Driven to Distraction: Technology is Changing the Way We Read

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Driven to Distraction: Technology is Changing the Way We Read

Once I was a scuba diver in the sea of words. Now I zip along the surface like a guy on a Jet Ski.~ Nicholas Carr

When I write about fanfiction in general, I tend to look at the way we receive it, the things which draw us in and keep us captivated. Rarely do I talk about the things that don’t and I’m not alone in this. The reality is, whether consciously or not, I just don’t tend to think about it. Yet when I stop for a moment and consider fanfiction as an online mode of written communication, I come to the startling conclusion that as much as well-written fanfiction keeps me entertained; it can also prove to be an infernal distraction. Whether I like it or not, spending endless hours trawling through online fanfictions or fanfiction blogs, when I should be focusing my attention on something more productive, is symptomatic of a wider problem that comes from being “wired 24/7” (Kennedy, 2010: 6) to the internet.

As Cate Kennedy illustrates in her article, Driven to Distraction (2010), “the technology [that] was supposed to free us” (5) to use our time more productively and efficiently – “enabling us to work anywhere…on our own terms” (5-6) – has actually “begun to train our brains for speed rather than mindfulness” (6). Consequently, when I sit down to write a paper or read a book, I am constantly distracted by the things around me – the need to check my email or Facebook, the need to look up something on YouTube, the need to quickly read an updated chapter from my favourite fanfiction. In an effort to tick all of this off my list, however, my attention has to be stretched across several different activities at the same time and like most human beings I’m not that good at multi-tasking. As a result, therefore, I become incredibly “distraction-prone” (Kennedy, 2010: 5). The problem is we don’t really think about what we’re losing in the process. Take the writing of this blog, for example:

 In the past few days I have simultaneously been telling myself that this post needs to be completed whilst finding multiple reasons not to write it – I’ve read multiple chapters of multiple fanfictions, surfed the net for articles about the impact of online reading and spent time on Google images, YouTube and Facebook. If I wanted to be really difficult, I could even decide that I was in desperate need for a walk to clear my head but even then I would pick up my iPhone to check my emails and plug in my iPod to distract me on the way out of the door.

Rarely, if ever, will I complete something academic without doing all this. Like millions of other internet users out there, I’m eternally distracted. The problem is, just like fanfiction, I never seem to be able to really log off. And I’m not the only one.

Every minute of every hour of every day, someone is actively online reading someone else’s fanfiction. As one user updates their story in Germany, another is commenting on it in France or Brazil. As that comment is posted, someone is Russia is reading the review and deciding whether or not it is worth their attention, whilst at the same time someone in Japan is uploading a new fiction for readers to explore. Simultaneously, yet unaware, these users all actively contribute to a never-ending cycle dictated by a satellite connection and the click of a mouse. To complicate matters further, the success of the writer relies upon the recognition of the global reader. In today’s networked society, however, the reader’s attention is increasingly distracted by the continuous updates and the multitude of voices active in the online community. As a consequence of this, a small minority of writers emerge out of the white noise to become fanfiction royalty, whilst the majority of online stories are tossed aside into the proverbial trash heap. Even I can’t deny that, having read so many inspirational fanfictions by so many brilliant writers, the sheer multitude of voices has meant that my ability to remember them in any detail is diminished. As much as I want to, I simply can’t remember them all and this is not something which is isolated to fanfiction alone – even my ability to read and reflect on paperbacks has been affected. The question is why?

According to Cate Kennedy, the information overload experienced by internet users has changed the way we read and think about things on the web. She writes that “when we read something on the web, we skim a paragraph or two, conduct a quick gist harvest and move onto the next story” (Kennedy, 2010: 8). Rarely do we conduct deep reading or have the time to stop and reflect upon what we have read – and this is exactly what happens when I read fanfiction, first skimming the first chapters for the storyline and then quickly skipping over the details I don’t have time to read. Nicholas Carr, in his 2008 article Is Google Making Us Stupid? expresses similar sentiments, reflecting that as the “Net [has become] a universal medium” for information dissemination, it “seems to be…chipping away at my capacity for concentration and contemplation”. Citing Marshall McLuhan, he writes that “media are not just passive channels of information…but [that] they also shape the processes [of our] thoughts”, impacting upon the way we interpret the information before us. In her article Proust and the Squid: The Story and the Science of Reading the Brain, Maryanne Wolfe expressed her own budding concerns “that the style of reading promoted by the Net, a style that puts “efficiency” and “immediacy” above all else, may be weakening our capacity for the kind of deep reading” that emerged with the printing press (Carr, 2008). Simply put, according to the above academics, our ability for deep reflection and increased concentration skills for long periods of reading and writing have been diminished by our internet use. Despite its obvious advantages and the incredibly creative products which are produced by fanfiction writers, I have little doubt that that internet has changed the way we think. Like it or not, accept it or not, technology is changing the way we read.

References:

All images cited from GoogleImages

Carr, N (2008). “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” The Atlantic Magazine July/August, [online] accessed 22 October 2012, http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/is-google-making-us-stupid/306868/

Hiatt, M (2010) “The Crowd is Our Domain”, Overland 201: 81-85.

Kennedy, C (2010). “Driven to Distraction”, Overland 199: 4-9.

Continnuum Reccomends: Twilight Fanfiction

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Continuum Recommends: Twilight Fanfiction

The Unaccompanied Soul by JMCullen09

 His fingers pressed against the flesh covering my heart and he suddenly smiled – his eyes no longer held that distant look. They were once again staring into mine. There was so much emotion there, pulling me in and showing an opening into his soul – which nearly left me winded by what I saw. ~ Chapter 15, A Piece of Beautiful.

There’s something special about JMCullen09’s writing you don’t see everyday – an ability to convey human emotion in a way that it leaps off the page and into your heart. You don’t have to have read Twilight to understand this story; you don’t have to know anything about Twilight at all. What you need is a heart.

Isolated in an old, dilapidated mental hospital on the outskirts of Forks, this Edward Cullen has never experienced the outside world. Ripped from his childhood, abused and abandoned; Edward’s past isolates him from the present. Bella, on the other hand, sits very much inside the world of the living and it is her belief in the ghost stories that lead her to Edward’s home. Shocked to discover the beautiful boy hidden away in the dark with his teddy bear Lancelot, Bella is instantly drawn to the most vulnerable being she has ever met. As she discovers more about Edward, she unlocks more about his past, meets the man who has spend much of his life caring for a boy who is afraid to recognize his existence (Marcus) and falls in love.  Enduring, heartbreaking and insightfully beautiful, JMCullen09’s story is not to be forgotten. 9/10.

Wisp by Cris 

Adorable? Yes, actually, she was. She was a beautiful young woman, even emaciated and covered with the visible marks of terrible abuse. Not only that, but her childlike actions and the way her big brown eyes watched him kindled something inside him—a strange protectiveness he’d never felt before for anyone. ~ Wisp, Chapter 2.

Wisp Banner by Judo_lin

It’s rare to come across a fan fiction that has the ability to break your heart within the first few chapters. It’s even rarer to find a story that deals with controversially dark themes such as the psychological repercussions of sex slavery in such a humane manner. But this is what Wisp does and it does it well.

Discovered in the back of a truck following a well-intentioned poker game by Edward, Wisp (Bella) is a broken human being. Sexually abused, treated like an animal and terrified of the furniture, the Wisp Cris creates is vulnerable, terrified, broken and bare. Yet behind the fear is an amazingly beautiful human being with the ability to communicate her feelings to the people she trusts (and distrusts) and the relationships she builds with Edward and Rose are painfully beautiful. Although still currently a work in progress, Wisp is one of those stories which makes you thankful for what you have and who you are. 9/10 (With a sound warning about the mature content – dark themes and painful angst).

Cris’s interview about Wisp and the background behind both the writer and the story can be found at Twific Central. (Hint: This fanfiction author has never read a Twilight novel!)

http://twificcentral.com/tag/wisp/

The Long Walk Home by bsmog

I can’t remember what it feels like to have one whole day when I’m not walking. Or fighting. We only stop walking to fight. Then we bury our brothers and our cousins and our friends and pick up our wounded and start walking again. Only way a man doesn’t have to keep walking is if he’s hurt bad or dead. ~ The Long Walk Home, Chapter 1.

Set in Civil War era America, on the eve of Gettysburg, this is the story of three confederate soldiers – Edward, Emmett and Jasper – broken by their experiences at war. As they stop one night on what they think is a deserted homestead, these three soldiers stumble across the three women who will change their lives forever. Faced with the unrelenting reality of war and duty, however, these soldiers will come to discover that it will take more than just their loyalty and brotherhood to keep them all alive. Especially when Edward discovers that what binds him and Bella together is more horrifying than anyone could have guessed – what would you do if you met the love of your life, only to discover it was at your hands that her husband was killed in battle?

Amazingly well written, historically accurate and insightfully original, this story is well worth the read for any Twilight or historical fiction reader. 8/10.

Cold Blood? Twilight Fanfiction

Tags

, , , , , , , , ,

Cold Blood? Twilight Fanfiction

And so the lion fell in love with the lamb…what a stupid lamb…What a sick, masochistic lion ~ Edward Cullen & Bella Swan, Twilight (Chap 13, pg. 274)

Twilight Fanart by Alice

(Source)

I’m not going to shy away from revealing that I have read all the twilight books. In fact, I might even go as far as admitting that I am a closeted fan of them. Having completed the Harry Potter Series for the second time in less than two years, I came across a curious novel written by Stephanie Meyer – Twilight. Although I can’t recall exactly what it was that drew me to the novel, I know that within minutes of picking it up for the first time I was simply unable to put it down until I finished and, being a closeted Team Edward supporter, I have no qualms admitting that I was equivocally horrified by the second novel’s introduction of Jacob Black as Bella Swan’s love interest in New Moon. Of course, anyone who’s read the fourth and final novel, Breaking Dawn, will be well aware that Edward gets the girl and Jacob…well, let’s just say Resemme still has some growing up to do. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg, don’t forget these Vampires sparkle.

The Twilight Saga is a worldwide teen phenomenon. With Four novels, five blockbusters, countless Teen Choice Awards, soundtracks, merchandise, promotions and two of the most recognizable young actors in Hollywood playing the lead rolls, the supernatural world Stephanie Meyers creates in Twilightis difficult to avoid (even by the most passionate haters).  I myself can’t claim to have much knowledge about the films themselves, the books, however, are another matter entirely. Having waited anxiously for months before it was released, I won’t deny that I was excited enough to complete the final 754 page monstrosity in just under two days. I wanted to read more. That’s when I discovered the extraordinarily diverse world of Twilight Fanfiction.

(Source)

When one considers that the Twilight Saga is so wrapped up in the supernatural, it may seem strange that so many of the fanfictions published online contain the stories of human characters. Whilst many of Meyer’s characters retain certain personality traits which make them unmistakably, well, them, the world of Twilight fanfiction is remarkable for its ability to take the reader away from the vegetarian, fangless, sparkling vampirism of the original novels to the profoundly human realities of their stories. In this world, Edward is a handsome surgeon, dangerous mob-boss, rich CEO, broken widow or single father. Jacob is the gay best friend, violent ex or smiling child. And Bella is the meek literature student, the confident editor, trustworthy friend and opinionated assistant. Time periods are relative, relationships are optional and circumstances are variable. It’s just as likely that your favorite characters wake up married in Vegas as it is that Bella will be taken back to 1918 to meet Edward before he became a vampire. And if that’s not enough, Alice, Emmett, Rose, Jasper, Esme, Charlie, Carsile and Renesmee are all along for the ride. With human characters such as this, it’s of little surprise that that the Kirsten Stewart cheating scandal of a few months of go had fanfiction authors posting apologies with their updates about cheating related content that they added to their fics. And if that’s not enough, some stories are written in reaction to events that happen in everyday life.

(Source)

In saying this, however, I am not in any way denying that canon, vampire related fics have been written, some spectacularly so. In fact, to say such a thing would be sacrilege…but my aim here is to present a side of fanfiction which really reflects the creative potential of the internet medium. Twilight fanfiction is incredibly interactive and international, it’s worldwide following make’s it popular but the imaginative capacity of some authors is truly awe-inspiring. Stephanie Meyers, in an interview regarding Twilight fanfiction, remarked that she herself had mixed feelings about the venture. Speaking candidly, the Twilight author admitted that it “has become a kind of a mixed thing for me” (Meyer, Twifans Twilight Fan Community, 2010) to read the fanfiction, stating that she would rather young authors use their talents to publish their own original work, although revealing that she didn’t mind the stories which took her characters out of cannon, such as all human (AH) stories. Not surprisingly, novels like the controversial Fifty Shades of Grey were originally composed as Twilight fanfictions before the names were changed for publication, something which Meyer argues makes them uniquely someone else’s creation. All human fanfictions, therefore, have the creative capacity to become something more than just a recycled storyline and for many, their talents have been used for an even greater cause: Fandom Gives Back.

Created in November 2009, Twilight Fandom Gives Back is a charitable writers group which auctions off members fanfictions to raise money for Alex’s Lemonade Stand Foundation for Childhood Cancer. According to a 2009 CNN ireport, the organization raised a remarkable US$12, 637. 39 within the first day of the original auction, more than US$2,000 over the original target of US$10,000. By the time that particular auction was over they had raised over US$ 82,000. Remarkably, Twilight Fandom Gives Back is only one of many charitable fanfiction organizations affiliated with the online fanfiction community intent of making a difference in the world. Keeping this in mind, it seems to me that the human element of twilight fanfiction extends far beyond the original pages, into the hearts and minds of Twilight fans online. And I for one, am proud to say I am one of those readers.

Fandom Gives Back!

http://thefandomgivesback.blogspot.com.au/

http://lion-lamb.livejournal.com/8013383.html

 References:

Genet, A (2010) “Stephanie Meyer Talks ‘Twilight’ fan fiction & ‘Breaking Down’ (her own private FF)”, Twifans Twilight Fan Community [online] accessed October 15 2012 at http://twifans.com/profiles/blogs/stephenie-meyer-talks-twilight

Meyer, S (2005). Twilight. London: Atom.

SE1901 (2009) “The Twilight Fandom Gives Back”, CNN iReport [online] accessed October 15 2012 at http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-357908

Vacant Reflection: The Politics of Self-Amputation

Tags

, , , , , , , , , ,

Vacant Reflection: The Politics of Auto-Amputation

Self-amputation forbids Self-recognition ~ The Extension of Man by Marshall McLuhan

We’ve all felt it – the frightening loneliness of being surrounded by a sea of people, none of whom know your name or care in the least how you came to be there. It’s not something we readily identify with, but everyday as I board the train, I join the sea faceless millions on my commute into the city center.  I stand, pressed against the doorway, as hundreds of other commuters rush towards the platforms, never stopping, never looking, never seeing. I plug my iPod into my ears, drown out the voices of those who surround me and endeavor strongly to look anywhere but the person across from me. If I feel like it, I read a book to pass the time, never failing to notice how the other faceless people in the carriage with me seem preoccupied with their own realities. Occasionally, but rarely, someone will speak to the person beside them and the recipient of that voice is forced to make a decision: to respond or to develop temporary deafness. And if in doubt of the speaker’s character, which in such a hostile environment is not all that unlikely, the recipient will simply respond them look away.

In a world where we are constantly surrounded by people, continuously together but totally alone, it seems strange that we as social beings relentlessly hide amongst the sea of faceless millions. But I even I can’t deny that we do and it’s not a modern affliction.

Over a century ago, nineteenth century Englishmen awoke to the realization that industrialization, the growth of the working class and the emergence of the modern city had rendered many of them faceless figures in a lonely crowd. To the people of nineteenth century England, this was a new phenomenon – the constant alienation of those around them, an inability to recognize the individual amongst the collective and the increased loneliness of living in a city of millions without personally recognizing a single face was a frightening experience to grapple with.

Nineteenth century industrial and Victorian novels are full of such images of alienation and faceless crowds, whether it be the ferocity of the revolutionary crowd in Charles Dickens’s A Tale of Two Cities, the implicit but corrupted poor of Bleak House’s London or the working class of Elizabeth Gaskell’s Mary Barton, the ever present impression is a universal collective defined by those around them. Individual identities seem like something of the ever present past, something privileged, something real, but something hidden. In midst of such trauma, and with the loss of traditional associations and pastoral landscapes, human beings began to define themselves, not with the social frameworks of their world, but with reference to the people who surrounded them, their values, beliefs and activities. As a consequence, however, we became numb – we forgot how to recognize the self. That does not mean, however, that we forgot how to be individuals.

 In his work Understanding Media: The Extension of Man, Marshall McLuhan discusses auto-amputation as a means of coping with technological change. He argues that “by continually embracing technologies, we relate ourselves to them as servomechanisms…extenstions of ourselves” (McLuhan, 1964: 46) which forces us to “numb our central nervous system” (McLuhan, 1964: 47) to deal with the shock of transition. With auto-amputation, however, comes a level of numbness, an inability to recognise a part of the self that has always existed. Just like John Barton is unable to associate with the consumerist window displays alien to the industrial worker in Gaskell’s Mary Barton, so too do we lose a level of recognition.

We’re constantly surrounded by people, but we are increasingly unable to communicate with strangers on the bus. Why? Because the extention of telecommunications technology has meant that everywhere we go, every footstep we take, we are constantly connected to each other via online networks. We become dependent on our mobile phones, laptops and iPods; we read eBooks on tablets instead of novels and we chat through Face book instead of picking up the phone. They give us a sense of individualism – the internet connection allows us to share our thoughts and stories, communicate with each other and gain access to information at the click of a button. In doing so, however, we don’t associate with people like we used to…we are always together, always communicating, but we are always somewhere else as well (Turkle, 2010: 152). Just like when I am responding to a blog or reading a fanfiction, I could be reading something else as well – but i’ll never remember the fanfiction like I did the book because I’m distanced from the text. I’m lonely in the crowd.

References

All images cited from GoogleImages

McLuhan, M. (1964) Understanding Media. London: Routledge & Kagan Paul.

Turkle, S. (2010) Alone Together: Why We Expect More From Technology and Less From Each Other. New York: Basic Books.

Magical Moments: Continuum Recommends

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Magical Moments: Continuum Recommends

It’s important to remember that we all have magic inside of us ~ J.K. Rowling

Albus Dumbledore once said that “in dreams, we enter a world that is entirely our own” (Steve Kloves, writer of the screenplay for Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban), a world where our deepest desires, imaginings and realities come to life before the eyes of the beholder. It is in this imaginary world that we can re-create the realities of everyday life, build something magical, and craft something fantastical. Yet, as J.K. Rowling once cautioned through the very same influential character, in Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, “it does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live”.

In an online world teeming with magical creations, the stories which make up the online Harry Potter fanfiction community capture some of the most diverse voices on the net. From what if variations of Harry Potter’s final years at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, such as Seritha’s Twist of Fate series, to James and Lily’s unwritten love story, comedic variations of the original plot and dreary explorations of Severus Snape’s jaded past, Harry Potter fanfiction has it all. Ever wondered if the hateful relationship between Draco Malfoy and Harry Potter was concealing something else? Hundreds of slashfic writers have – the Harry/Draco ship is the most popular slash genre in this fandom. What about Sirius Black and Remus Lupin? Lev Grossman certainly highlights this “unexposed [surface]” (2011) from the original narrative which stories such as remuslives23’s It Was Only a Kiss or Dwight4Studly’s Harder than the First Time certainty support. Then there’s the AU (alternate universe) fics which are totally removed from cannon (original narrative world), for example Hgfan1111’s Knotted which mixes the Harry/Ginny romance with Disney’s Tangled. And don’t forget stories which expand and re-explore events which occur in the novels, such as Kb0’s A Friend Indeed and Harry Potter: Unchampion.

With so much variation to choose from, and with so many different genres, it is difficult to recommend Harry Potter fanfictions. As a result, the fictions recommended below, as well as those mentioned, are some of my personal favourite contributions to the Harry Potter world.

The stories we love best  do live in us forever…[and] Hogwarts will always be there to welcome you home. ~ J.K. Rowling

Remember by Sbmcneil

I will make no secret of the fact that Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is one of my favourite Harry Potter novels, but having read them all I came to question the consequences of the events of the novel on the  lives of Harry Potter and Ginny Weasley. Emotional, creative and perceptive, Sbmceil’s Remember explores the aftermath of the chamber arc years in an alternative universe where Harry and Ginny, having attended separate schools in the aftermath, have no memory of Tom Riddle or the chamber ever existing (and to complicate matters, neither do the people around them). This novel length story explores a world where all the characters have their own personal and interwoven stories, intrically connected by their relationship to the main characters and their loyalty to the light. Not only does this fic explore other dimensions of our favourite characters (Mrs Weasley and Albus Dumbledore being two of the most interesting), but it brings in a story about love and trust central to the soul-bond narrative. In this story, the connection between Harry and Ginny is, on a supernatural level, far more mature, complex and magical than readers of cannon would be used to. In a world where Voldemort is at large and Harry still has a destiny to fulfill, this fanfiction is one of the best. To discover the truth behind their hidden past, confront the present and fight for a tomorrow, then this fanfiction is well worth the read. 8/10.

Easier to Be by Hgfan1111

This is an Alternate Universe (AU) fanfiction set in the post-Hogwarts years in a world where Harry and Ginny have never previously met. Masquerading as muggles in London to escape their dark pasts, and having never met each other before, Harry and Ginny must first find themselves before they can face the world together. Flawlessly written, heart-breaking and hopeful, this fanfiction explores the lives of two people living together in disguise, not realising that what bonds them together goes deeper than mere magic. 7/10.

Unintended Consequences by Sbmcneil

When I read Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, I instantly started asking the question what would have happened if Harry, Ron and Hermione became permanently separated? What if their friendship wasn’t quite strong enough? In Unintended Consequences, Sbmcneil explores this idea, starting from the night Ron storms off in the Forest of Dean, only in this story Hermione follows him and their disappearance has far-reaching consequences none would have predicted. Facing the Horocrux hunt and his ultimate destiny alone, Harry must take control of his life. Joined by Ginny after he rescues her from a dire situation at Hogwarts and his pet kitten Sparkle, this is the tale of what would have happened if Harry was forced to fulfil his own destiny without his non-so-loyal best friends. Beautifully written and emotionally driven, this story features a more mature Harry and Ginny as they face down the man who destroyed their innocence: Tom Riddle (Voldemort). Complex and multi-layered, exploring the alterative stories of all those involved (i.e. Ron, Hermione, Remus, Tonks), this is a must read for any Harry Potter fan. 9/10.

Any of the Fic written by the below writers are also worth the read:

References:

All images cited from GoogleImages

Grossman, Lev (2011) “The Boy Who Lived Forever”, TIME Magazine, 7 July, accessed 20 September 2012, http://www.time.com/time/arts/article/0,8599,2081784-3,00.html

Magic Pandemonium – The Harry Potter Series Online (how we are changing the story and what JK Rowling has to say)

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

We do not need magic to transform our world. We carry all the power we need inside ourselves already. We have the power to imagine better. ~ J. K. ROWLING

When J.K Rowling published her debut novel Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone in 1997 it is doubtful that she realized the impact her magical creation would have on a generation of readers. Six novels, eight movies and millions of dollars worth of Harry Potter merchandise later, the Harry Potter brand had bewitched the world.  Simple in its language, mysterious in its building plot and powerful in its moral messages, The Harry Potter Series has long been credited for “[teaching] a generation of children about the power of fiction” (Sandstrom, 2007) and, if the thousands of Facebook users who describe to “We Are the Harry Potter Generation” fan pages is any indication then this assumption is not far off the mark.

I, myself, have no reservations admitting that I was one of those subscribers who, in the excitement of the release of the final installment Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II proudly ‘liked’ the Facebook page “3 heroes. 7 Books. 8 Movies. 10 years. We are the Harry Potter Generation” – but I was only one of 236, 489 people worldwide. Unsurprisingly, Facebook itself is inundated with Harry Potter related pages, from “We all have a filthy muggle friend that doesn’t like Harry Potter”to a page dedicated to Ron Weasley’s famous quote “Why Spiders? Why couldn’t it be follow the Butterflies?” Add this to the sheer number of Harry Potter YouTube videos, including the incredibly successful A Very Potter Musical, along with the numerous fansites and fanfiction archives; it becomes increasingly evident that the Harry Potter online phenomenon is as far-reaching as the series itself. But these numbers seem incremental when compared to worldwide booksales and movie premieres which broke all sales records, making both the novel and the film franchise readily accessible to millions of readers all around the world. I won’t deny either that I was one of those readers who pre-paid months in advance for the release of the final book in nervous anticipation about the fate of our boy hero (I was subsequently determined that if Harry was to die then I would no longer be a fan of the series!).

The phenomenal power of the Harry Potter Series is not something to be underestimated, but for all their popular support, it is the transformative magic of the novels that captured the imagination of a generation of computer literate readers. Telling an incredibly moving tale about love, loss, life and the realities of humanity – the Harry Potter novels appeal to the reader because of their ability to identify with the characters, to feel the emotions described in the text and imagine the magic in a world so far removed from our own. The world of Harry Potter is far from idealistic, dementors sap the happiness from all those who come into contact with them, a sociopathic murderer becomes obsessed with his own immortality at the expense of our boy hero, human turn into animals, animals transform into humans, wizards play their own version of football up in the air, children grow up abused without their parents, others grow up in loving families and mythical creatures long lost in the tales of ancient stories come to life before the very eyes of the reader. With its universal appeal, it’s not hard to understand why so many are enthralled by a series so complex in structure yet so accessible in form. The imaginative power of the Harry Potter Series, however, extends far beyond the books, movies and merchandise to a whole new world created by the fans themselves, the online world of Harry Potter fan fiction.

Fan Art by October_Song

With over 77,000 stories archived on the site Harry Potter Fanfiction.com and another 608,702 complied on Fanfiction.net; Harry Potter fan fiction is one of the largest fan fiction communities in the world, encompassing a wide arrange of genres, themes and audiences which creatively transform the cannon Harry Potter world. The numbers recorded here reflect just the tip of the iceberg of this massive fandom, with thousands of bloggers, forums and archives dedicated to other aspects of the enormously popular text. From stories telling the tale of James and Lily’s years at Hogwarts, to OC pairings of characters incompatible with the novels, from what-if scenarios that change the fate of the characters to soul-bond fictions binding characters together telepathically in a whole new storyline. Ever wondered what would have occurred if Harry went back in time to re-do his past mistakes? If his parents had never died? If he took control of his own destiny? Or came out as gay?

The world of Harry Potter fanfiction is in many ways just as magical as the books themselves, creating an imaginary space where a new world is discovered on the fringes of our society. It may come as a surprise to some of you that a good handful of fanfiction writers pre-empted some of the main storylines of the final book before it was published (i.e. that Snape hadn’t really murdered Dumbledore in cold blood/loved Harry’s mother) whilst many others produced amazing continuations of the wildly popular Half-Blood Prince. In an article written for BBC News Rowling explained her support for the fanfiction community, stating: “that she is very flattered by the fact there is such great interest in her Harry Potter series and that people take the time to write their own stories” (Waters, 2004) based on her characters as long as it remained non-commercial and away from print publishing as not to exploit the fan community (Waters, 2004). Rowling is one of few authors who actively support the phenomena, but that being said her representatives also asked fanfiction writers to ensure that their works are not obscene, citing that the novels are intended as children’s novels and thus have a young audience (Waters, 2004). In endorsing such an act, Rowling actively extends the fandom beyond the written text to a world far beyond what she has imagined and yet not so far removed. It is a magically creative phenomena far from slowing down.

If we’re the proud Harry Potter generation, why not continue the magic?

References:

All images cited from GoogleImages

Sandsrom, K (2007) “How the Harry Potter Phenomenon Changed Children’s Literature”

Waters, D (2004) “Rowling Backs Potter fan fiction” BBC News Online

The Unnatural Technology of Reading and Writing

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

The Unnatural Technology of Reading and Writing

Reading takes us away from home, but more important, it finds homes for us everywhere.   ~  Hazel Rochman

Henri de Montaut “A Reading With the Concierge 2nd Half of the 19th Century”

On February 16th 1792 Thomas Paine published the second half of a work of intellectual revolutionary literature, entitled The Rights of Man, in response to a fervent debate over monarchical tyranny and aristocratic privilege in the ‘Age of Revolution’. Reacting against Edmund Burke’s 1790 pamphlet Reflections on the Revolution in France, Paine’s work was a defense of democratic republicanism and natural rights against the hereditary power of ‘old’ government in Europe. Written in a way that appealed to the common masses, and historically selling thousands of copies within months of publication, the pamphlet “prompted an array of responses” (Grogan, 9) throughout the civilized world at a time when the print media was emerging as a popular political force (and per-empted government censorship in Britain).

The debates which originated from this period survived in written form and the ideals they presented now underpin much of our modern notions of democracy, representation and social equality. Texts which followed, including the Chartist Poetry of the 1840s crying the miseries of the poor, Victorian literature providing scathing social  commentaries of industrial working class life and the emergence of the shorter detective/realist novel of the late 19th century (following the 1870s Education Act which drastically increased literacy) all contributed to an evolving print culture. They were texts that brought people together, that encouraged debate within a growing public sphere and encouraged critical reflection about what was written – significantly, they were texts which had to be carefully read and which carried important messages from generation to generation.

Given the long history of the type of literature mentioned above and its influence on the development of print culture, it may seem strange that I am including it in a discussion about technology. After all, it’s simply human nature to read and write isn’t it? There’s nothing mechanical about it, right?

Centuries of reading and writing have taught us that these processes are simply part of ‘natural’ human progression, that it’s our ability to think critically about ideologies which sets us apart from other species which roam this earth. Yet despite many inferences to the contrary, Walter Ong clearly illustrates that there is nothing ‘natural’ about writing at all. In fact, he emphasises that human beings “have interiorized the technology of writing so deeply that…we cannot separate it from ourselves or even recognise its presence or influence” (Ong, 24). Seen as “something to be manipulated, something inhuman, artificial [and] manufactured” (Ong, 27), the very act of writing (and therefore reading) involves processes of expression, critical thinking and reflection which aren’t necessarily part of who we are but what we have chosen to become. Embedded so deeply in society, in a way that underpins our understanding of modern civilization, the technologies of reading and writing seem naturalized in literary discourses, often making us forget that 6,000 years ago we lived in an oral culture.

So why then, is this important and what does it have to do with Thomas Paine or 19th century print culture?

When we think of reading and writing as naturalised we often overlook the shift to digital technologies as an extension of an existing practice. When I read a blog post or a new chapter of someone’s fanfiction I don’t think about the processes I am going through or that maybe someone has done it before me.  This in itself links directly to my point about Tom Paine: in writing in such a direct way as to accommodate the common man, whilst at the same time exalting a voice than reverberated throughout the Atlantic world, he, like everyone else, was disseminating information to the wider public for critical reflection. The authors and poets who followed were likewise voicing an opinion and getting their messages across in a universally understood format. They wouldn’t have thought there was anything particularly unnatural about publishing their thoughts on paper.

The practices of blogging, and of writing fanfiction, therefore extend this existing technology – in providing a space for the development of a voice, opinion or reflection they too invite a response from the reader to further a viewpoint or argument. The value in digitization, therefore, is the act of providing a voice not matter how hard it is drowned out – the difference is, with so much information literally at our fingertips and so little time in which to reflect upon it technology has changed both the way we read and our interaction with the written word. What Tom Paine embodied, and what bloggers and fanfiction writers alike illustrate, is that as writing evolves so too does our reception to it. It’s something to be thought about next time you decide to read something online.

References

Paine, Thomas. Rights of Man. Ed. Claire Grogan. Ontario: Broadview Editions (Broadview Press), 2011.

Smith, Olivia. The Politics of Language 1791-1819. New York: Oxford University Press, 1984.

Ong, W. (1986) ‘Writing is a Technology that Restructures Thought’ pp. 22-50 in G. Baudmann (ed) The Written Word: Literacy in Transition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Continuum Recommends

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Life seems but a quick succession of busy nothings ~ Jane Austen

(Source)

It is a truth universally acknowledged that every fictional adaption of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is subject to individual interpretation. As readers participating in an online reading community, with differing backgrounds, morals and beliefs, it is almost invariably certain that the work’s which stand out of the crowd for one person are not necessarily going to have the same illuminating effect on another. To complicate matters more, the proliferation of Jane Austen fanfiction available on the internet means that inevitably, some of the better works may be diminished by all the white noise surrounding them. As a consequence of this, the job of recommending Pride and Prejudice Fanfiction to potential readers is inherently difficult. Given this, the fictions highlighted in this section provide only a snapshot of some of the best Pride and Prejudice fanfictions I have personally come across in my six years of reading online fanfiction – and inevitably, these fictions are all well written in an accurate historical context.

Sharon Lathan’s The Darcy Saga

In late 2006, having divested my local library of all existing variations and continuations of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, I stumbled upon a fascinating piece of literary work being published online by Sharon Lathan. The fiction in question was The Darcy Saga and it was later to be published in three volumes entitled Mr & Mrs Fitzwilliam Darcy, Journey’s Beyond Pemberly and The Darcy’s at Year’s End.

Having become “bewitched body and soul” (Pride and Prejudice, 2005 Screen Adaptation, Joe Wright) in much the same way I was by Joe Wright’s 2005 screen adaption of the classic novel, Lathan’s work explores the Darcy’s first years of marriage. Written beautifully, it is a tale of “true love” in Austen’s Regency world that romantically, but somewhat realistically portrays the love and life of two of literature’s most cherished figures.

Now only available in published form, this was the story that introduced me to online fanfiction, a story which has since outgrown the medium that made it popular and transgressed back to the printed text from which the original story was born. For any Pride and Prejudice fan this is a must read! 8/10

Other recommendations include:

Works by Linda (booknut), Carol B, Enid Wilson, Abigail Reynolds,  Pat M (Pat),  Sara (Sadieo) and DebraAnne.

(Source)

Sharon Lathan, Novelist – Official Website

Jane Austen Fanfiction for Beginners

Austen Underground (JAFF Forum Site dedicated solely to the reading and writing of Jane Austen fanfiction/original works)

50 Miles of Good Road (JAFF Forum containing author’s works of current P&P fanfiction)

A Happy Assembly (JAFF Forum containing author’s works of current P&P fanfiction from the author’s of Meryton Reading Room and other promising writers)

Meryton Reading Room (A password protected archive of completed P&P fanfiction from the authors of A Happy Assembly. Some of the finest Jane Austen fanfiction on the internet is contained within this archive, with some of the stories available in a downloadable PDF format).

Austen Interlude (A selection of Jane Austen fanfiction authors who have published their works online, including the work of Abigail Reynolds , Susan B and Belen. Some of the stories are printable, whilst others have been removed for publication)

Derbyshire Writers Guild (A broad database of Jane Austen fanfiction covering all of the texts and screen adaptions. These fics are strictly pg-13 rated and those contained in the Epilogue Abbey are entirely well written. This is a massive database of Jane Austen Fanfiction and well worth exploring for any fan – Fantasia Gallery contains some of the more adventurous, non-canon variations. )

Mrs Darcy’s Story Site (New publications are no longer posted but the original fanfictions are still available to read online. Some of the earliest and best online P&P fanfictions can be found here, including Abby B’s Happenstance and works by Tanya)

Pride, Prejudice and Plagiarism? Jane Austen and Online Fanfiction

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

“It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.” – Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice (1813), Penguin Classics 1996.

When I was a child I didn’t read many books – in fact, the very act of reading seemed thoroughly abhorrent to me. If it didn’t have pictures and didn’t capture my imagination within seconds, then any literary form was inevitably tossed aside. In 2005, however, that mindset was irrevocably reversed when a screen adaptation of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice graced our screens for the first time.

As a young student thoroughly invested in history, and with a need to break away from my own reality, the dazzling world of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudiceimmediately captured my imagination. Having never read the text, however, this complex, comedic love story was somewhat difficult for my young mind to comprehend. Thoroughly enthralled in a way that I had never been before, the novel awakened me to the world of Jane Austen’s regency, a world of courtly manners, etiquette, class and society. To a place where one’s birth and material assets mattered more in a marriage than the concept of love and to a female character who, way ahead of her time, defied the expectations of her class in her determination to marry for nothing but love. It was a novel that became a timeless classic in the literary imagination, a novel that introduced me to the world of online fanfiction.

The world of Jane Austen fanfiction is well established in the online communities, full of stories imagining the continuation of the novel and the what-ifs that never eventuated. What if Elizabeth had been forced to accept Darcy’s first proposal? What if Lady Catherine never interfered? What if Elizabeth had never overheard Mr. Darcy at the Assembly? Or what if he apologized? Just think, what would the story have been like if Jane died from her illness or Elizabeth ended up with Mr. Bingley instead?

These are questions that the readers and writers of Jane Austen fanfiction have been exploring for years and in many senses the level of commitment to this fandom makes it an entirely creditable and elitist form of fanfiction to the ordinary reader. Underpinning this notion, however, is an age old critique – that fanfiction is, at its core, “simply the practice of writing…based on other people’s work” (Schaffner, 2009: 614). Those who reject fanfiction as such, generally tend to fall into the trap of believing it to be outright plagiarism and, without a doubt, there are some writers who could be rightly accused of this. For the most part, however, for those who understand the value of fanfiction, it is seen as a mode of expression neither intended to infringe copyright or produce profit. If you were to look at most contemporary fanfictions, you would see a disclaimer printed at the top of the work, citing the original owner of the foundational content and stating that only the adaption (not the characters, images, quotes or settings) belong to the writer.

This is an interesting question for Pride and Prejudice fanfiction because it is so prolific on the internet – the sheer mass of information available sometimes makes it difficult for even the seasoned reader to find the light at the end of a very long tunnel. One could easily assume, then, that Seth Grahame-Smith’s Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, Amanda Grange’s Mr. Darcy’s Diary, Sharon Lathan’s The Darcy Saga (all published versions of Jane Austen fanfiction) or the multitude of published works on fanfiction communities could also be classified as plagiarized work. Here’s the hitch – when Pride and Prejudice was published in 1813 there was no such thing as copyright, so although based on the work they are far more accepted than something based on Harry Potter ever would be (especially since trying to publish such a work would probably send the writer to court).

To the prolific reader of fanfiction, however, most works are accepted not as plagiarism but as works of expression –they don’t retell the same story, the re-imagine it. They engage a worldwide community and they inspire the next reader to write. Maybe that should be thought about next time plagiarism comes to mind.

References:

All images cited from GoogleImages

Austen, Jane. Pride and Prejudice. London: Penguin Classics, 1996.

Schaffner, Becca. “In Defense of Fanfiction.” The Horn Book Magazine, Nov/Dec 2009: 613-618.

The Wonderful World of Fanfiction

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Fanfiction: An Online Reading Community

To learn to read is to light a fire; every syllable that is spelled out is a spark.~ Victor Hugo

Upon reading the opening lines of this blog the reader will become acutely aware of its purpose. In fact, in the very act of reading these first few lines, they will become actively engaged in an online community of users not unlike the reading community upon which the world of Fanfiction is built. They will read, comment, reflect and critique – they will use their ability to read to fuel their own imaginations and they will begin to engage in a discussion about Fanfiction in general. Maybe they’ll accept the discussion or maybe they won’t – but that’s the whole point, isn’t it? Doesn’t the internet create a domain where we can freely express ourselves and our opinions? The world of Fanfiction certainly seems to think so, so too does the history of reading.

It is no secret, even in today’s information society, that reading and writing are ancient art forms. Before there were computers there were typewriters and before typewriters there were quills. Similarity, before there was the e-book there was the printed text and before the printed text there were scrolls. What we communicate isn’t really important here, but how we communicate it. Reading and writing form an integral part of our modern societies and the ability to engage in such processes allows our imaginations to expand beyond the limitations of existing plot lines. Fanfiction, then, comes from a type of curiosity, a need to reinvent a story or to change something to make it more likable. Fanfiction is a mode of creative expression where the reader becomes the writer, “using characters, settings and events from their favourite books, movies and television shows” (Burns and Webber, 2009: 27) to create their own stories from those already written. Fanfiction is by no means a new phenomenon, and it has its critics, but its value lies in the fact that it draws together a “large community of readers unconstrained by time, distance, age or talent” (Schaffner, 2009: 614) to a common point of interest.

It may therefore seem strange that I begin this voyage with a focus on Jane Austen’s Mansfield Park and the character of Fanny Price. You may ask yourself why I chose one of the least likeable of Austen’s heroines, why I chose to highlight a novel which even to its contemporaries met with critical reception. But that is exactly my point. Written and published during the late 18th and early 19th centuries (1790s-1810s), at a time when the novel was just beginning to emerge as a popular literary form, Austen’s work illustrates an awareness of the world she lived in and the realities of Regency society. Far removed from the novelties of the 21st century, with our technological capabilities and real time communication, Austen’s world was one of rigid class structure, decorum, privilege and compromise. It was a world where women were inferior to men and love was not a factor in marriage, but it was also a romanticized world of ballrooms and rake-hells.

To the modern reader, however, the work and protagonist remain simply unlikable to many. Fanfiction’s such as Katherine Taylor’s Everingham, therefore allow us to ask what if Henry did the right thing? What if Fanny was more outspoken? We can change the story, emphasize the points we like and discard the one’s we don’t. That’s the creative power of Fanfiction, that’s why I’m writing this blog and it’s why we bother reading Fanfiction at all.

References:

All images cited from GoogleImages

Schaffner, Becca. “In Defense of Fanfiction.” The Horn Book Magazine, Nov/Dec 2009: 613-618.

Burns, Elizabeth and Carlie Webber. “When Harry Met Bella: Fanfiction is all the rage. But is it plagerism? Or the perfect thing to encourage young writers?” School Library Journal, 2009: 26-29.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free