Tags
Blog, Cate Kennedy, Distraction, Driven to Distraction, Fanfiction, Internet, Marshall McLuhan, Maryanne Wolf, Nicholas Carr, Proust and the Squid, Reading, Technology
Driven to Distraction: Technology is Changing the Way We Read
Once I was a scuba diver in the sea of words. Now I zip along the surface like a guy on a Jet Ski.~ Nicholas Carr
When I write about fanfiction in general, I tend to look at the way we receive it, the things which draw us in and keep us captivated. Rarely do I talk about the things that don’t and I’m not alone in this. The reality is, whether consciously or not, I just don’t tend to think about it. Yet when I stop for a moment and consider fanfiction as an online mode of written communication, I come to the startling conclusion that as much as well-written fanfiction keeps me entertained; it can also prove to be an infernal distraction. Whether I like it or not, spending endless hours trawling through online fanfictions or fanfiction blogs, when I should be focusing my attention on something more productive, is symptomatic of a wider problem that comes from being “wired 24/7” (Kennedy, 2010: 6) to the internet.
As Cate Kennedy illustrates in her article, Driven to Distraction (2010), “the technology [that] was supposed to free us” (5) to use our time more productively and efficiently – “enabling us to work anywhere…on our own terms” (5-6) – has actually “begun to train our brains for speed rather than mindfulness” (6). Consequently, when I sit down to write a paper or read a book, I am constantly distracted by the things around me – the need to check my email or Facebook, the need to look up something on YouTube, the need to quickly read an updated chapter from my favourite fanfiction. In an effort to tick all of this off my list, however, my attention has to be stretched across several different activities at the same time and like most human beings I’m not that good at multi-tasking. As a result, therefore, I become incredibly “distraction-prone” (Kennedy, 2010: 5). The problem is we don’t really think about what we’re losing in the process. Take the writing of this blog, for example:
In the past few days I have simultaneously been telling myself that this post needs to be completed whilst finding multiple reasons not to write it – I’ve read multiple chapters of multiple fanfictions, surfed the net for articles about the impact of online reading and spent time on Google images, YouTube and Facebook. If I wanted to be really difficult, I could even decide that I was in desperate need for a walk to clear my head but even then I would pick up my iPhone to check my emails and plug in my iPod to distract me on the way out of the door.
Rarely, if ever, will I complete something academic without doing all this. Like millions of other internet users out there, I’m eternally distracted. The problem is, just like fanfiction, I never seem to be able to really log off. And I’m not the only one.
Every minute of every hour of every day, someone is actively online reading someone else’s fanfiction. As one user updates their story in Germany, another is commenting on it in France or Brazil. As that comment is posted, someone is Russia is reading the review and deciding whether or not it is worth their attention, whilst at the same time someone in Japan is uploading a new fiction for readers to explore. Simultaneously, yet unaware, these users all actively contribute to a never-ending cycle dictated by a satellite connection and the click of a mouse. To complicate matters further, the success of the writer relies upon the recognition of the global reader. In today’s networked society, however, the reader’s attention is increasingly distracted by the continuous updates and the multitude of voices active in the online community. As a consequence of this, a small minority of writers emerge out of the white noise to become fanfiction royalty, whilst the majority of online stories are tossed aside into the proverbial trash heap. Even I can’t deny that, having read so many inspirational fanfictions by so many brilliant writers, the sheer multitude of voices has meant that my ability to remember them in any detail is diminished. As much as I want to, I simply can’t remember them all and this is not something which is isolated to fanfiction alone – even my ability to read and reflect on paperbacks has been affected. The question is why?
According to Cate Kennedy, the information overload experienced by internet users has changed the way we read and think about things on the web. She writes that “when we read something on the web, we skim a paragraph or two, conduct a quick gist harvest and move onto the next story” (Kennedy, 2010: 8). Rarely do we conduct deep reading or have the time to stop and reflect upon what we have read – and this is exactly what happens when I read fanfiction, first skimming the first chapters for the storyline and then quickly skipping over the details I don’t have time to read. Nicholas Carr, in his 2008 article Is Google Making Us Stupid? expresses similar sentiments, reflecting that as the “Net [has become] a universal medium” for information dissemination, it “seems to be…chipping away at my capacity for concentration and contemplation”. Citing Marshall McLuhan, he writes that “media are not just passive channels of information…but [that] they also shape the processes [of our] thoughts”, impacting upon the way we interpret the information before us. In her article Proust and the Squid: The Story and the Science of Reading the Brain, Maryanne Wolfe expressed her own budding concerns “that the style of reading promoted by the Net, a style that puts “efficiency” and “immediacy” above all else, may be weakening our capacity for the kind of deep reading” that emerged with the printing press (Carr, 2008). Simply put, according to the above academics, our ability for deep reflection and increased concentration skills for long periods of reading and writing have been diminished by our internet use. Despite its obvious advantages and the incredibly creative products which are produced by fanfiction writers, I have little doubt that that internet has changed the way we think. Like it or not, accept it or not, technology is changing the way we read.
References:
All images cited from GoogleImages
Carr, N (2008). “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” The Atlantic Magazine July/August, [online] accessed 22 October 2012, http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/is-google-making-us-stupid/306868/
Hiatt, M (2010) “The Crowd is Our Domain”, Overland 201: 81-85.
Kennedy, C (2010). “Driven to Distraction”, Overland 199: 4-9.






















